African Stories in Hull & East Yorkshire
  • Home
  • Project
    • Stories archive
    • Contemporary Voices
    • Schools
    • Gallery
    • Further information
  • Blog
  • What's New!
  • About
    • Events
    • Exhibitions
    • Get involved
    • Media coverage
    • Contributors
    • Referencing
  • Contact

Research blog

Spot the difference!

6/12/2017

0 Comments

 
Below are two paintings believed to be by the popular local artist John Ward (1798–1849) who was one of the leading marine and ship painters during the early nineteenth century. Although, they appear to be very similar there is one important difference, can you work out what it is?
Picture
'View of the Humber No.4: The Citadel and entrance to the Old Harbour', Maritime Museum, Hull. M/F1/Merchant Shipping Room 2, KINCM.2007.1010
Picture
'Shipping Hull Garrison', Hull Museums, Not currently on display, KINCM:2006.9336
​Both paintings are set at the mouth of the River Hull and Humber shipping lane at sunrise with a view of steam and sailing ships in the background. Also featured in the paintings are lightermen rowing their small boats out into the river and two men in the midground looking out across the water, in what appears to be deep discussion. However, in the foreground of the picture there is a subtle but important difference. In the first painting, one man in red (possibly a dock worker), is seated on a rock or large piece of wood and appears to be smoking a long pipe. However, in the second painting this man is joined by an acquaintance who is seated to his left. The other gentleman is Black. He is wearing a yellow hat and light-coloured jacket with blue trousers and black shoes. He is also probably a dockworker and is smoking the same long pipe. Thus, while the first image shows an idyllic traditional and popular view of Hull’s maritime landscape in the early nineteenth century, the second painting represents a more faithful and accurate portrayal of actual Black presence within the port. 

​Undoubtedly, the paintings raise more questions than answers. It is believed that the second picture with the inclusion of the Black sailor was painted around 1800. If this is the case, then it could not have been painted by Ward since he would have only been two years old at the time. Given the scenery and artistic style of the work, it is possible that this early date is incorrect and that, in fact, Ward produced this work much later on. The first painting without the Black sailor has been dated to around 1835 and is believed to be by Ward.  This begs the question whether Ward made a copy of the older picture (perhaps by an unknown artist) and then deliberately removed the Black figure? Or did he make a copy of his own painting and add the man into the scene later on? And if so why remove or add a Black dockworker? Additional historical research and pictorial analysis would need to be done in order for these questions to be more fully answered. Nonetheless, the paintings and their story remain intriguing.
​
With thanks to Dr Nicholas Evans for bringing this to our attention. If you think you have any further information about either of these painting, please do contact us here.
0 Comments

    Follow us

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    April 2023
    June 2021
    March 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    February 2019
    December 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016

    Categories

    All
    1881 Census
    2016 Roundup
    2017 Catchup
    2017 Roundup
    2018 Roundup
    Abolitionists & Activisits
    Adolphus Meheux
    African Chiefs
    African Dancing
    African Presence
    #AfricansInYorks
    African Students In Filey
    Afro-Caribbean
    American Archives
    Bevereley
    Beverley Treasure House Exhibition
    Blackbird Theatre Group
    Black History
    Black Servicemen/women
    Blaire Cunningham
    Brandesburton Pygmies
    Bridlington
    Bud Sugar
    Call For Information
    Chiedu Oraka
    Children's Homes
    Clive Sullivan
    Contemporary Voices
    Cottingham Servicemen
    Dennis Fyle
    East Yorkshire Research
    Emancipated Slaves
    Events
    Exhibition Comments
    Exhibition Guided Tours
    Family Histories
    Filey
    Garabu
    Goole Museum Exhibition
    Happy New Year!
    @HeritageLottery
    Heritage Lottery Fund
    #HLFsupported
    Hull City Of Culture 2017
    Hull Exhibition Roundup
    Hull Fair
    Hull History Centre
    Hull Maritime
    Hull Maritime History
    Hull Museums Collection
    Hull Sailors
    Hull Trawlers
    Human Curiosities
    Hymers College
    Ivan George Exell
    Job Vacancy
    John Ward Hull Painter
    Josiah Henson
    Jubilee Singers
    Leon Riley
    Lest We Forget
    #LoveHeritage
    Market Weighton
    Military History
    Moses Roper
    National Archives
    New Material
    New Project Feature
    New Release Schedule For 2018
    New Research
    Nick The Cook
    Olaudah Equiano
    Opening Night
    Oral Histories
    Our Histories Revealed Exhibition
    Paul Robeson
    Peter Fryer
    Photo Gallery
    Picture Blog
    Picture Gallery
    Project Study Day
    Queen's Gardens
    Racial Equality
    RAF
    Remembrance Sunday
    Research
    Roy Francis
    Rugby
    Samuel Samei Marco
    Save The Date!
    Schools
    Schools Study Day
    Sculpture
    Servicemen
    Sierra Leone
    Sport
    Sudanese Officials
    'Uncle Tom'
    University Of Hull
    War Graves
    Who Do You Know?
    Wilberforce House
    Wilberforce Monument
    William Wilberforce Monument
    WISE
    WWII

​All work (and images) published on African Stories in Hull and East Yorkshire is the intellectual property of its creators and requires permission to be republished or reproduced.

If you wish to use any of the images on our website, please submit an enquiry via the Contact page.
​
Stories
Contemporary Voices
Blog
What's New!


Schools
Get involved
Media coverage
Events
About
​Meet the team
Referencing
Contact
© Copyright 2024 African Stories in Hull and East Yorkshire.
  • Home
  • Project
    • Stories archive
    • Contemporary Voices
    • Schools
    • Gallery
    • Further information
  • Blog
  • What's New!
  • About
    • Events
    • Exhibitions
    • Get involved
    • Media coverage
    • Contributors
    • Referencing
  • Contact